Wednesday, October 02, 2013

How We Can End The Government Shutdown and Improve Education at the Same Time

The conflict over passing a budget for the federal government centers around how we as a society should ensure that all citizens have health insurance. The current Affordable Care Act takes a three-pronged approach. (1) Healthy people will pay more in insurance so that high risk people can pay less insurance. (2) There are government subsidies to supplement the cost of purchasing insurance depending on family income. (3) Set restrictions on how much insurers, doctors, and hospitals can charge. The Democrats are willing to hold the government hostage to defend this marginal approach. Alternatively, the Republicans are willing to hold the government hostage to replace the Affordable Care Act with equally marginal approaches, such as, (1) funneling federal subsidies for health insurance to individuals through tax credits as opposed to funneling federal subsidies through tax free fringe benefits and (2) creating competition in the insurance marketplace by allowing individuals to purchase insurance across state lines. Both of these approaches focus on how to pay for health care. Neither one focuses on how we can reduce the costs of health care.

I don't pretend to be an expert on health insurance policy, but it strikes me that basic principles of supply and demand seem to be ignored on both sides of the aisle. As the population of the U.S. grows, as baby boomers reach retirement age, and as more people get health insurance, the demand for doctor's visits continues to rise. Yet, the supply of doctors has been flat for around 20 years. What students learn in Economics 101 is that when demand rises in the face of fixed supply, the cost of the product or service will rise or supply will be reduced when price is restricted from rising. Policy makers should not be surprised that the cost of doctor's reimbursements in the U.S. are higher than in any other country and we are seeing increasing scarcity of access to doctors.

Since 1990, the U.S. population has risen 25% from 250 million to 310 million. Yet, the number of medical residency slots remains fixed at the 1990 level of around 100,000. Without completing a residency, a medical school graduate cannot practice medicine. Therefore the number of doctors we produce each year is fixed. Currently, the federal government pays for these residencies through medicare. There has even been debate about reducing the number of slots that medicare will fund as a way to reduce medicare expenses. I have not researched the history of the development of the policy of why the federal government pays for all of the residency costs, but it would seem that through some combination of expanded federal funding, funding from insurance companies, and funding from hospitals, we should be able to dramatically increase the number of residency slots and thus the number of doctors will rise. If we end up with a glut of doctors, Economics 101 suggests that access to health services will increase and the price for those services will stabilize or decrease.

One countervailing concept from Managerial Economics is that as you expand the labor supply, there is likely to be a diminishment in the quality of labor, since you have first selected all of the best so the remaining pool is necessarily of lower quality. However, we can expand the supply of doctors significantly without lowering standards. Our population has expanded by 25% in 20 years. Unless our education system is worse than it was 20 years ago, we are producing 25% more qualified candidates of the same quality that we had 20 years ago. In addition, there are many reasons to believe that our education system is better and we are have much higher rates of college completion than we did 20 years ago. So there is plenty of excess capacity to expand the number of doctors. This seems like a straightforward solution to reducing the costs of health care and obviating the need to hold the government hostage over how to pay for health insurance.

The educational benefit of expanding the pool of doctors is that premed faculty would have to shift from being gatekeepers of the medical field to becoming teachers that actually try to get as many people to understand science as possible. We could pass a corresponding legislation called No Doctor Left Behind that holds college faculty accountable for the number of premed students who fail to graduate with medical school acceptances. We can label those colleges with high dropout rates as medical dropout factories. And those with differential passing rates by race and socioeconomic status can be labeled as failed premed programs. One consequence of this policy might be that premed programs will stop wasting doctors' time studying irrelevant content and shape a program around those math and science concepts that relate to human biology. Focus and relevance are the very things that help all students learn.

As we bemoan the hiatus of government services, it would be helpful to shift the focus away from one crisis to the next and begin to direct our focus on long-term solutions that benefit both our health care system and the education of our next generation.


Sunday, September 01, 2013

It's Time to End Affirmative Action as We Know It

"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness."  Declaration of Independence

In the context of heated conflict about specific strategies for implementing the principle of equality for all, it is important from time to time to return to the foundational principles that form the basis for how our society should be structured. Even though our country has not always lived up to the principle of equality or upheld each person's unalienable Rights, these foundational principles are something that we can all agree on.

The current chapter in the fight to neutralize past inequalities unfolded this past June in Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin. The Supreme Court upheld the legality of universities considering race in their admissions decisions. However, the Supreme Court narrowed the scope of race-conscious admissions policies by requiring that the consideration of race be used only as a last resort to maintain a critical mass of minority students. The decision to uphold the use of race hinges on sociological evidence that student body diversity is a college dimension that leads to a host of desirable academic outcomes for all students. Therefore, the Supreme Court has deemed that is permissible to admit less qualified minority students in order to maintain a critical mass of minority students on campus.

In its idealized form, affirmative action does not advocate any specific strategy for increasing diversity. Instead, affirmative action is a generalized principle regarding the importance of taking proactive steps to eradicate the vestiges of legalized discrimination:

“Affirmative action does not mean entitlements to proportional representation. It means action to eliminate discrimination: creation of more adequate talent pools, active searches for talent wherever it exists, revision of policies and practices that permitted or abetted discrimination, development of expectations for a staff whose composition does not reflect the impacts of discrimination, provision of judicial process to hear complaints, and the making of decisions without proper regards to sex, race, or other origin.” (Reed, 1993, 1-2)

In this idealized form, it is difficult to rationalize opposition to the idea that as a country we should eradicate the effects of past discrimination. Unfortunately, the implementation of affirmative action in higher education over time has devolved into and become equated with race-conscious admissions policies.

The term affirmative action was first introduced by John F. Kennedy in 1961 as an executive order mandating that all government contracting agencies hire and treat employees without regard to race, creed, color, or national origin. In 1965, Lyndon Johnson built upon JFK's executive order by requiring all government contractors to document the affirmative steps they have taken to increase representation of women and minorities in the workplace. In 1969, Nixon went a step further by requiring federal contractors in Philadelphia, and then other cities, to meet specific quotas for hiring African American employees, which became known as the Philadelphia Plan.

Universities followed the lead of the Philadelphia Plan and began setting aside specific slots in the admissions process for minority students. For example, the medical school at the University of California - Davis set aside 16 out of 100 medical school slots for minority students. A medical school applicant, named Allan Bakke, sued the university when he was denied admission (Bakke v. Regents). In 1978, the Supreme Court found that setting quotas was unconstitutional, but did not strike down the the idea that universities could consider race as a goal. The idea of race-conscious admissions policies was challenged again in the case of  Grutter v Bollinger, which was decided in 2003. The Supreme Court upheld the idea of using race as one consideration among many in the admissions process, but made clear that the consideration of race should no longer be necessary in 25 years.

There have been a variety studies investigating the relationship between race-conscious admissions policies and the resulting levels of desegregation on college campuses.

  • A recent study found that the long-term enrollment trends for black and white students have shown increasing tendency towards integration, which suggests that race-conscious admissions policies are working. However, most of the increased integration occurred during the era of specified quotas prior to Bakke v. Regents. Since the early 1970s, the trend has shown gradual increase, but has mostly been stagnant. In fact, the same study suggests that states that have banned race-conscious admissions policies at public universities have seen increased integration.
  • When examining income disparity, socioeconomic data show that the representation of upper income students has increased at selective colleges since the late 1970s, while the representation of lower income students has remained stagnant. Therefore, the most economically disadvantaged minority students are not benefiting from race-conscious admissions policies.
  • Some have argued that current forms of race-conscious admissions policies mainly benefit descendants of recent immigrants or children of biracial couples, not children whose four grandparents are descendants of slaves. It is “students like these, disadvantaged by the legacy of Jim Crow laws, segregation and decades of racism, poverty and inferior schools, who were intended as principal beneficiaries of affirmative action in university admissions.”
  • In the wake of the Grutter v Bollinger decision, a group of researchers explored the likelihood that race-conscious admissions policies could be eliminated by 2028 as suggested by Justice O'Connor in the Grutter decision. Projected decreases in income gaps between families of black and white students as well as increased K12 school integration will have small effects on the ability to eliminate race-conscious admissions policies. The biggest hope for eliminating the need for race-conscious admissions policies by 2028 would be reducing the test score gaps between black and white students.
In all of this historical effort to defend the constitutionality of race-conscious admissions policies, there seems to be little discussion about the effectiveness of the strategy. Taking the long-term view, there seems to be very little impact of these policies on creating a sustainable trend to reverse the effects of discrimination. The tragedy of the legal fight around race-conscious admissions policies is that the legal arguments on both sides continue to reinforce the idea that test scores are what defines qualification for college entrance. The opponents of race-conscious admissions policies argue that test scores should be the primary determinant of college entrance.They believe that using race to trump test scores should be unconstitutional. The proponents of race-conscious admissions policies concede that tests are the primary determinant of college qualifications, but argue, and the Supreme Court agrees for now, that race should be allowed to trump test scores as a means for overcoming past injustices.

In contrast to the central role that test scores play in the fight to eliminate past discrimination, test scores play a minor role in predicting actual student outcomes. By design, ACT and SAT scores are meant only to predict a student's first year GPA. At the very heart of the college entrance decision is estimating the level of performance of first year students in large, introductory survey courses. These are the same courses that have been shown to negatively correlate with important qualifications for high quality medical and engineering practice. The same can be said of the LSAT legal entrance exam. Any important quality of legal practice that is not predictive of first year law school grades has been eliminated from the LSAT test.

Even when we narrow our focus on what the entrance exams are designed to do, it becomes troubling to think that they play such a central role in the debate around race-conscious admissions policies. Studies that have examined how well students at selective schools performed in their first year courses based on their test scores have only been able to account for about one-third of the variability in first year GPA. That means that two-thirds of the reasons why students do well or don't do well in their first year classes is explained by other factors. The impotency of college entrance exams is amplified when attempting to predict overall college performance and eventual career outcomes.

In commemoration of the 50th anniversary of Martin Luther King's "I Have a Dream" speech, it is useful to juxtapose the history of the SAT that is at the core of thwarting King's dreams. The first SAT was administered in 1926; nineteen years before the first computer (1946); twenty-five years before the cognitive revolution which challenged the very foundation of the SAT (1950s); twenty-eight years before Brown v. Board of Education (1954); and 37 years before the March on Washington (1963). In the face of technological, social, and psychological revolution over the past 87 years, the SAT has merely tweaked its name and its scoring methodology, but fundamentally remains the same test that was developed during the heart of our discriminatory past.

It is had for me to believe that such a vestige of our troubled past will ever be the road to fulfilling King's dreams. Instead, I firmly believe that if we scrapped the entire admissions process and built a new one from scratch with modern ideas of the American dream and taking advantage of modern technology and modern cognitive science, we would have a fundamentally different system that would end the need for affirmative action and give everyone one an Equal shot at a high quality of Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness. That is my dream.


Wednesday, June 05, 2013

Rahm Emanuel's Intuition-Based Reform

Rahm Emanuel is about to unleash the greatest carnage on public schools in our nation's history. Both the Chicago Public Schools' school board that he appointed and the CEO that he appointed have reviewed all of the data, listened to public comment, and determined that the trauma of closing 50 schools and displacing 30,000 students will be in the best interest of students and parents in the long run. This decision makes intuitive sense according to the portfolio management model that is in vogue in many school districts. In this model, if a school is not helping the vast majority of its students to meet the standards there must be something wrong with the school, the administration, and its teachers. This portfolio model of school management is metaphorically similar to how brokers manage stock portfolios. Brokers buy and sell stocks based on which company is performing well. If one company is not performing well in the stock market, brokers will move their money (e.g., children) to a different company that is performing well. By actively managing clients' money and making smart decisions about which company will be performing well, brokers get the best return on investment. High quality brokers get insanely rewarded for high returns on investment, irregardless of the impact on companies, communities, and the environment for those investment decisions. Also the riskier the investment the greater the reward, but also the easier to be discarded for one bad investment decision (see the rise and fall of the London Whale).

Last month's decisions by the CPS school board is the culmination of almost a decade of operating under the portfolio management model. In 2004, CPS initiated the Renaissance 2010 initiative, under Arne Duncan, that sought to create 100 new contract schools by 2010. These contract schools could be discarded after 5 years if they are not performing well. The portfolio mentality seeped into the management of the neighborhood school. If a neighborhood school is not performing well or becomes underutilized because students go to other schools, it too can be discarded. In fact from 2001 to 2009, 44 schools in CPS were closed for underperformance or underutilization (p. 1). As is promised now, the district had promised that students who are in closing schools would be sent to higher performing schools and our overall return on investment would increase for the district as a whole.

As much as this makes sense if take the perspective of thinking about schools the way stock brokers think about their money, let's evaluate CPS's past return on investment from their portfolio approach as a gauge for the likelihood of success for their future portfolio management.  A recent report from the University of Chicago's Consortium on Chicago School Research (CCSR), evaluated CPS's return on investment of their portfolio of underperforming schools from 2001 to 2006. In that time frame, CPS closed 38 schools. In other words, CPS sought to move their children from lower performing schools to higher performing schools to boost the return on the overall portfolio. These school closings were smaller in scale than the current 50 and spread out over 5 years, as opposed to one year. Since there were a relatively small number of schools that closed each year, the district could focus their efforts on actively managing the portfolio of students to ensure they were placed in new schools that had higher average performance on standardized tests.

CCSR found that students who transferred to schools performing in the top 25% of the portfolio did indeed score higher in both reading (1 month higher) and math (almost three months higher) than they would have had they stayed in their closed school. However, only 6% of the students from closed schools were placed in these top performing schools. Those schools were on average 3.5 miles further from home than their closed schools. The overwhelming majority of students ended up at schools in the middle to lower end of the CPS portfolio. A year later in their new schools, students on average scored equivalent to what they would have done had they stayed at their old school. In other words, after five years of active portfolio management of 38 schools, the return on investment is zero. Some students did better, some did worse, but overall the portfolio remained unchanged.

If a bank allowed a stock broker with a track record of zero return on investment to double down on their investment with a much riskier bet, the bank would be hauled before Congress. When JP Morgan Chase was hauled before Congress over the London Whale, they were chastised for letting a broker with a track record of outstanding returns place a huge bet that failed. In the public sector it is much easier to second guess the private sector than it is to second guess and hold themselves accountable. While these data only point to a failed implementation of the portfolio model, it also raises the question of whether the value system that treats children like money that can be shifted around at will can really be successful at all. Perhaps even a slight shift towards a socially responsible investment approach might be an improvement in which the broker chooses the best possible investment that balances both the return on investment as well as the overall social good of the investment. Perhaps a zero return on investment would be more palatable if the carnage to local communities had been minimized.

Wednesday, May 01, 2013

In the Garden of STEM

"April showers bring May flowers," is a common expression in the midwest of the United States. Those April showers also bring May weeds. The state of Illinois lists the dandelion as an official weed. Dandelions are particularly pernicious for homeowners as they have evolved to bring joy to children. When the dandelion flower turns to seeds, it looks like a cotton ball. The gentle blowing of a child's breath sends the seeds floating on the wind like summer snow to spread throughout your yard and your neighbors' yards. Homeowners spend countless hours either pulling these weeds from their lawn or spreading weed killer.

I often think of the dandelion when I hear college students discuss their experiences with premedical science classes. I look upon those students and wonder whether they are a medical dandelion or a medical flower. Built into the core of premedical education is the notion that students who do not have the aptitude for medical school should be counseled out of notions of continuing their medical education. In other words, courses should be designed to weed these students from the garden of STEM. These courses are commonly known as weed out classes. This core characteristic of premedical education dates back to a 1950s medical education report: "Effort should be made as early in the student's college career as possible to determine whether, on the basis of personality, character, motivation, and academic performance, he is qualified to go into medicine. If it is decided he is not qualified, then every intelligent device, including aptitude and interest tests, should be used to persuade him to reevaluate his professional objective." (1953 Survey of Medical Education, p. 11)

What do these medical dandelions look like? At Stanford University, as well as many other universities, medical dandelions are most likely women, African American, and Hispanic. Caucasian males are least likely to become medical dandelions. Given that there is no evidence to suggest that women, African Americans, and Hispanics are inherently inferior doctors, there must be something wrong with what we conceive to be important in preparing students for medical school.

Every weed, pest, and invasive species has a place on Earth where they belong and are treasured. The dandelion comes from Eurasia. It was brought to North America by European immigrants. The dandelion has many positive attributes. In the garden, the dandelion helps other plants by making nutrients available, attracting pollinators, and enhancing the process of fruit ripening. In the kitchen, the dandelion is used to make salad, wine, coffee, and as an ingredient in root beer. In medicine, the dandelion has been used as an herbal remedy to treat infections, liver problems, and urinary difficulties. Thus, unbeknownst to many homeowners, there are places on Earth that grow the dandelion on purpose for sustenance and medical treatment.

In medical practice, empathy is a practice that patients highly value from their doctors. It is the ability to relate to another person on an emotional level. Since the vast majority of time we need to see a doctor, we are in a heightened emotional state, it is greatly appreciated to be cared for by someone who understands what we are going through. However, empathy is another one of those dandelions that is weeded from premedical education. Several studies have found that performance in the weed out science classes is actually negatively correlated with empathy. One study (p. 123) concluded that: "students with high achievement in many components of the curriculum tend to have personality profiles that seem inappropriate for their chosen careers as physicians."

About 90% of medical schools follow this paradigm of premedical education requirements. The lack of empathy in the medical profession is well portrayed in a 1991 movie called The Doctor, starring William Hurt. It is based on the true story of a surgeon who made fun of doctors who showed empathy, until he contracted throat cancer himself and got to experience medicine from the patient's perspective. It changed the way he viewed the role of empathy in medicine. It would be nice if medical schools and premedical education embedded empathy into the core of their education programs.

One notable example of university that highly values personality characteristics is the DeGroote School of Medicine at McMaster University in Canada. Entrance to their program is not determined by how well students did in the weed out science classes. Instead, roughly one-third of the entrance score is based on overall GPA, regardless of major, one-third is based on a verbal reasoning score, and one-third is based on a personality assessment. Ranking on these scores is used to select for an on-site interview, which focuses on personality characteristics. Entrance to the medical school is based on the combination of both general academic strengths and personality characteristics. The result is that roughly 10% of the class comes from majors outside of science, such as the humanities, business, education and journalism. In the end, a McMaster student's undergraduate field of study does not predict the quality of their performance as a doctor.

Diversity matters in ecology and it matters in education. Declaring a plant as a weed based on one characteristic eliminates consideration of the variety of benefits that it has for the ecosystem. Likewise, weeding out premedical students based on only one of the characteristics of good physicians diminishes our access to individuals who are superior on many other qualities that make a good physician. I wish that universities would alter their selection criteria to focus on what actually matters for any given profession instead of using one yardstick to weed out the very qualities that we value.





Monday, April 01, 2013

The Election of Pope Francis Highlights that Everyday is April Fools' Day

If you believe that this essay was posted on April 1, 2013, you can thank Pope Gregory XIII. If you identify the date this article was posted in some other fashion, April Fools' Day is for you.

Prior to 1582, much of the world used a calendar that was developed under Julius Caesar, known as the Julian calendar. The Romans identified January as the first month of the year. However, there were many people who recognized March 25 as the beginning of the new year. Because of Easter, they would celebrate the new year on April 1. The Julian calendar has a technical problem in how it handles leap years. The days have been slipping for centuries. By the mid 1500s, the date of Easter no longer aligned to the lunar cycle. The current difference stands at 13 days behind the Gregorian calendar. Thus, April 1, 2013 in Gregorian is March 19, 2013 in Julian. This issue was known by astronomers for centuries, but no one had an alternative.

Pope Gregory XIII enlisted the best minds and made a commitment to correct the technical problems with the Julian calendar by adjusting how leap years are handled. The purpose of the Gregorian calendar was to establish the dates of Catholic feast days. Over the course of the next few centuries, the Gregorian calendar became the accepted secular calendar in most countries. Those countries that adopted the Gregorian calendar also adopted January 1 as New Year's day. In the United States, January 1 is the legal holiday for New Year's day.

Unfortunately, during the long transition from the Julian calendar to the Gregorian calendar, there remained confusion about when New Year's Day should be celebrated. There were those that adopted January 1 as New Year's day and those that continued to celebrate April 1 as New Year's day. These latter celebrants were known as April Fools. They were often the butt of practical jokes.

What started as good natured humor has become a daily barrage of name calling (and calling people fools would be a step up from today's discourse). It is common practice now to resort to name calling whenever people disagree about religion, politics, and social issues. Even when people are attempting to serve the common good, they routinely tear down those who oppose their ideas. Rather than address the issues directly, opponents are attacked personally and it is not good natured humor. In his most recent inaugural address, Obama called for an end to name calling in politics. In his book on the Five Dysfunctions of a Team, Lencioni highlights mistrust among team members and unhealthy conflict as two foundational dysfunctions of effective teams. Calling people fools (and worse) breeds division and mistrust not only in teams but also communities and society.

During his mass of installation last month, Pope Francis gave a different message for serving the weakest and the poorest in the world:  we need to serve one another with love and tenderness. Jesus Christ calls upon us to love our enemies. To be called a child of God means you must be a peacemaker (Matthew 5:9). In  Jesus' last public prayer,  he called for unity (John 17: 20-21) as the ultimate strength. Conflict is inevitable and healthy when focused on the issues and not the person. Pope Francis' message is that these conflicts should be rooted in love for one another. That is the hallmark of a Catholic as well as most religions.

Although religion has been crowded out of the public, political sphere, it is a unifying force within communities. In searching for empirical solutions, it would be helpful if political leaders actually paid attention to empirical data. There is ambiguous data at best that firing teachers and principals and closing schools leads to better outcomes for children. There is also empirical evidence that these strategies make children's lives worse. However, there is empirical evidence (p. 178, Figure 6.7) that the social bonds of the community surrounding a school can ameliorate the effects of poverty on children's lives. In particular, poor communities with high percentages of religious participation in the community achieved higher outcomes in their schools than poor communities with lower percentages of religious participation in the community. Rather than stamp out religion from the public sphere, we should be embracing religion as a powerful tool for community building and school reform.

Pope Francis' message calls for an end of everyday as April Fools' day and calls for embracing service with love for another as the means to protect and serve the world's most vulnerable people.


Friday, March 01, 2013

The End of My Writer's Block with Educational Lessons from One of the "Worst American CEOs of All Time"

"Oh, darn writers block
Why is my mind in a lock?
It's taking over my mind
Oh, the right words are so hard to find

I think my sanity is gone
'Cause this writer's block has lasted far too long
Why can't I get the words dead-on?
Every single word I write seems wrong!"

- Boo to Writers' Block by fruitilicious


It only took me six entries into the relaunch of my blog before I felt like I was in a rut. I found this poem on the Internet and it captures where I have been at mentally with my blog for the last several months. I truly admire those people who can maintain a relevant voice on a regular basis. My goal is to publish an essay each month that attacks traditional notions of what education is and provides a vision of what education can be.

Back in November, I wrote about the outbreak of teacher strikes in Illinois schools this year. Even last month, West Chicago District 33 was the latest to go on strike. In my November essay, I argued that the new evaluation system based on student test scores has broken down any remaining trust between teachers and administrators. Much of the ongoing rhetoric around the new teacher evaluation system reminds me of Jack Welch, the high flying CEO of General Electric (GE) during the dot-com craze of the late 90s. For my December entry, I had planned on writing an essay about Jack Welch's management philosophy of measuring the quality of everything using Six Sigma and annually firing the bottom 10% of managers, which sounds a lot like the rhetoric around measuring students in every subject and firing teachers and principals and closing schools based on the results. The danger is that we measure the wrong thing and fire the wrong people. However, I could not get the right angle on an essay about Jack Welch and GE.

I finally figured out that the interesting story is not Jack Welch, but instead the relevant story is Robert Nardelli, who was one of Jack Welch's lieutenants. When Jack Welch announced he would be retiring by 2001, there were two other lieutenants, who with Nardelli, were all vying for Jack Welch's job. In those days, Robert Nardelli was known as "Little Jack" for his similarities to Jack Welch. Although he personified much of the Jack Welch philosophy, he was not selected as Welch's successor. Instead, GE selected Jeffery Immelt. Home Depot wasted no time in hiring Nardelli as its CEO.

At Home Depot, Nardelli quickly instilled the Six Sigma discipline and overhauled the company, including shifting from full-time to part time staff. Through Nardelli's cost costing and standardization, Home Depot doubled revenue and profits in 5 years. Just like Home Depot, districts can get large test score gains by overhauling school structures, installing outcomes-focused principals, and standardizing the curriculum.

However, investors saw a different picture of Home Depot. Home Depot's stock price remained flat during Nardelli's tenure. Meanwhile, the stock price doubled at Home Depot's main competitor - Lowes. In addition Lowes was gaining market share against Home Depot and had significantly higher customer service ratings.

The problem for Home Depot was that the Jack Welch/GE management style destroyed Home Depot's competitive advantage. The full time store employees were all home improvement experts in their own right. The Orange Apron culture was a force to be reckoned with. They could give trusted advice to customers about what products were needed to accomplish their home improvement project. In addition, there was an entrepreneur culture at each store, which allowed the stores to respond to local conditions. Replacing the experienced full time staff with part-time, inexperienced staff and standardizing the store management led to inferior customer service ratings, declining same store sales, and flat stock prices.

This imposition of the wrong management style earned Nardelli a place on the list of Worst American CEOs of All Time. In fact, the Jack Welch management philosophy is not even relevant at GE anymore. Welch's successor, Jeffery Immelt, revolutionized the corporate culture at GE. He squelched the focus on process improvement and instead focused on creating new business through innovation. Eight years ago Businessweek declared that the most successful companies in America are those that focus on design and innovation. Apple and the new GE were the poster children of this declaration.

Last month, the Chicago Public Schools announced the potential closure of 129 "underpeforming" schools in Chicago. The students in those schools will be transferred to other schools that are "higher performing." CPS is taking a page out of Jack Welch's outdated, irrelevant play book. Unfortunately, this model has been proven destructive when applied in other industries. Early indicators show that the teacher and principal firing and school closing policy that is sweeping the nation is heading down the Home Depot road. Instead of increasing the quality of teachers that displaced students get, a University of Chicago study shows that, "The teacher workforce after interventions across all models was more likely to be white, younger, and less experienced, and was more likely to have provisional certification than the teachers who worked at those schools before the intervention." (p. 3) Just like at Home Depot, the policy is shifting the workforce from experienced to inexperienced teachers that have little connection to the local communities.

As a footnote to the Nardelli story, when the next Home Depot CEO reinstated the experienced workforce and reestablished the entrepreneurial culture, Home Depot gained ground on Lowes and is better positioned today for growth when the housing market recovers. If our education leaders are going to look to the corporate world for management models, it is imperative that they focus on up-to-date successful business models to emulate and attract high quality teaching staff by creating cultures of innovation rather than standardization.

Friday, November 09, 2012

This Year's Outbreak of Illinois Teacher Strikes is Oxymoronic

When Illinois enacted new education reform through Senate Bill 7 in June 2011, Arne Duncan praised the passage of the legislation by saying, "While some states are engaging in noisy and unproductive battles around education reform, Illinois is showing what can happen when adults work through their differences together. Illinois has created a powerful framework to strengthen the teaching profession and advance student learning in Illinois." I argue that, contrary to Secretary Duncan's assertion, the legislation has merely replaced noisy and unproductive battles with quiet and subversive battles. The legislation enacted a whole slew of "reforms" that made the state eligible for Race to the Top funding. The most touted components of the bill are authorization for a longer school day for Chicago schools, making it more difficult to obtain tenure, making it easier to revoke tenure and making it more difficult to strike. There was also companion legislation passed prior to Senate Bill 7 that changed the teacher evaluation system to include standardized criteria for classroom observations and student test performance.

It is ironic that in this new era of cooperation among adults in Illinois, there have been more teacher strikes in the first year of implementation than in any other times in the recent past. In fact it had been over two decades since the previous teacher strike in the Chicago Public Schools. This time around, over 90% of the teachers in Chicago voted to strike which was well over the new threshold of 75% set by Senate Bill 7. Given the poor working conditions and relatively lower pay for Chicago teachers, you might think that it makes sense that teachers in Chicago would strike over being asked to work 25% more time for a 2% raise in pay. The progress and outcomes of the Chicago strike were tracked in much of the national media.

Less well known outside of the Chicago area was the first ever teacher strike in Lake Forest, where the average teacher pay is over $100,000 per year. In addition, there have been strikes in three other Chicago suburbs, Highland Park, Prairie Grove, and Evergreen Park, with varying levels of teacher pay. There were strike notices, but no strikes yet, in three other districts with unresolved contracts. Five strikes out of eight strike notices is an unusually high percentage. There were varying issues in play within each school district, but one theme that cut across all the districts is, ostensibly, dissatisfaction with the pay raise offered by each district.

However, I think there is a more fundamental reason why there is an outbreak in teacher's anger over pay. Teachers have suffered through layoffs and pay freezes for over four years. For the most part teachers have been patient with school districts and have understood that economic conditions require everyone to tighten their belts. But SB 7 has changed everything. Even though Secretary Duncan argues that it is a model of cooperation, in reality it reminds me of President Reagan's oxymoronic relationship with Russia around nuclear arms: "Trust, but verify"

Reagan no more trusted the Russians than SB 7 trusts anyone in education. In one fell swoop every IL administrator's authority to evaluate was summarily revoked in June 2012. All administrators had to participate in roughly 40 hours of retraining on how to evaluate with the new system. The reformers believed it was essential to throw the entire education system in IL into chaos to ensure that those districts that have over 90% of their students meeting the standards do a better job of determining whether their teachers are adequately performing. In addition, for those schools where 90% of the students are failing to meet the standards, the reformers felt that principals needed a solid evaluation system that would allow them to accelerate the granting of tenure to high performing teachers or to dismiss unsatisfactory tenured teachers, if the schools ever reached a critical mass of tenured teachers, instead of constantly have to scramble to fill new positions.

Just as Reagan used his "Trust, but verify" mantra as subterfuge to dismantle the Russian military in the Cold War, reformers are using the mantra of accountability as a quiet and subversive battle to dismantle the teacher union even though there is no discernible evidence that their reforms will have any impact on the lives of children. In fact, it is easy to see that the reformers "have no clothes" when you look beyond the rhetoric and realize that this complicated evaluation system fundamentally relies on data that does not exist for many teachers. There are no state assessments in IL for any areas of social studies, most areas of science, art, music, kindergarten, 1st grade, 2nd grade, 9th grade, 10th grade, and 12th grade.

Another sign of the non-data-drivenness of data-driven reformers is the absolute dismissal of the data establishing the fundamental importance of trust and collective responsibility in sustaining long term growth in student learning. The "trust, but verify" teacher evaluation assault on the teaching profession destroys the very trust and collective responsibility that is the foundation for true reform in our schools. There is no doubt that we need to rethink our human resource management of schools, but we need forward thinking not rehashing of ideas that are even considered out dated by many in the corporate world. Next time I will elaborate on the tectonic shift in thinking about how employees are valued in today's successful corporations.


Thursday, September 20, 2012

The Boy Scouts vs Ralph Waldo Emerson

The motto of the boy scouts is "Be prepared." Legend has it that when Robert Baden-Powell, the founder of the boy scouts, was asked, "Be prepared for what?", he responded, "Be prepared for anything." I think Baden-Powell's view of the boy scouts sums up modern education. The boy scouts program aspires to prepare boys with life skills and values of good citizenship. To advance within the boy scouts, each participant needs to accumulate merit badges to among other things demonstrate that they can navigate without a compass, serve as a cook during a campout, and transport someone who might be trapped in a smoke-filled room. By completing the required merit badges before the age of 18 and being an active member of a troop for a specified period of time, boys are prepared to move on to the next level and eventually become an eagle scout, which is the pinnacle of a boy's scouting career.

Likewise, the motto, "Be prepared for anything," rightly characterizes modern education. You never know when you will need to solve a quadratic equation, explain the function of the endoplasmic reticulum, or describe the origin of a word. No matter how long you stay in school if you don't collect your quadratic equation badge, endoplasmic reticulum badge, your word origin badge, and all of the other required badges, you don't get to move on to the next level and eventually become a Boston College eagle, Bridgewater eagle, Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University eagle or any other form of college animal.

The boy scouts and modern education are also parallel in their lack of relevance to urban youth. In recent years, the national boy scouts organization has tried to expand participation among urban youth. It is a difficult challenge to help urban youth see the importance of learning to make camp gadgets out of rope. As a consequence, less than 11% of boy scouts are low income urban youth. Likewise, only around 11% of students at competitive colleges are low income youth. While a preparation for anything benefits the vast majority of society, there are far too many children in our society for whom a preparation for anything is actually a preparation for nothing.

In contrast to a preparation focused on everyone achieving roughly the same set of standards or merit badges, Ralph Waldo Emerson focuses on individual greatness as an essential component of a productive society. A key metaphor for Emerson's notion of greatness comes from a lecture given by professor Michael Faraday in 1848. Faraday explained the concept of diamagnetism, namely that each substance has its own unique polarity. Whereas, the polarity of iron tends to run from north to south, the polarity of other substances have their own unique direction. Likewise, Emerson believes that "every mind has a new compass, a new north, a new direction of its own, differencing its genius and aim from every other mind."

Emerson goes on to say, "A point of education that I can never too much insist upon is this tenet that every individual man has a bias which he must obey, and that it is only as he feels and obeys this that he rightly develops and attains his legitimate power in the world. It is his magnetic needle, which points always in one direction to his proper path, with more or less variation from any other man's. He is never happy nor strong until he finds it, keeps it; learns to be at home with himself; learns to watch the delicate hints and insights that come to him, and to have the entire assurance of his own mind." In other words, school standardization is the antithesis of greatness.

It is unfortunate that at the dawn of public education in the United States around the middle part of the nineteenth century, the winning educational design that has stood the test of time over a century and a half is one that is predicated on a common set of basic standards that all educated children must possess before they can pursue greatness in college. Quite the contrary, the implication of Emerson's philosophy is that we should as quickly as possible let students pursue greatness. It is through specialization that students will learn the academic standards in a relevant manner. I would further speculate that a significant underlying basis for the income disparities in learning outcomes is not that higher income families can better support students in the pursuit of the standards, but rather that higher income families can use their financial resources to help their children pursue greatness with a specialized education that schools cannot provide.

The myth of the 20th century civil rights movement is that equalizing the education system for all would bring about equality. I think Emerson would have foreseen the abject failure of trying to create a system that is the same for everyone. Today's civil rights movement should abandon the pursuit of mediocrity through standardization and instead should focus on transforming our education system into one that uniquely supports all students in the pursuit of greatness.

Saturday, August 25, 2012

What the Olympics Can Teach Us About Education

The London 2012 Olympics have been over for two weeks and I am sill experiencing withdrawal symptoms. The Olympics pack the adrenalin rush of an entire sports season into a 2-week period. There are so many amazing stories of incredible athletes, from newcomers to experienced athletes.

One of the first U. S. gold medalists was Kim Rhodes for skeet shooting. She practices 7 days per week at a cost of $700/day in ammunition. Her thousands of hours of practice paid off in an Olympic record of 99 hits out of 100 moving targets. She also set a record by winning a medal in five straight Olympics.

Brendan Hansen had retired from swimming after the 2008 Beijing Olympics. He started competing in triathlons to stay in shape. As a triathlete, his love of swimming was rekindled. He decided to make a comeback for the 2012 London Olympics. Although he only achieved a bronze medal in his signature 100 m breaststroke event, Hanson reported that he had worked the hardest for this bronze medal and it was his most treasured accomplishment.

In the 2008 Beijing Olympics, Michael Phelps established a new standard by winning more medals in one Olympic game than any other athlete. He accomplished what everyone hoped and expected he would, which created intense pressure. At the London games, Phelps was poised to shatter the lifetime record for the number of Olympic medals. However, this time around, the Olympics was much more fun for Phelps. After all that he has accomplished at the Olympic level, Phelps' enjoyment is seeing how much more he can accomplish: ''Now it's just a matter of how many toppings I want on my sundae.''

In track and field, the women's 100 m hurdles was an exciting race. Five women ran faster than the winning time from the Beijing Olympics. One of the finalists, Canadian Phylicia George, didn't start running track until she was in the 10th grade. Although she started her career relatively late, she made the Canadian team and ran her personal best in the finals. She did not make the medal stand, but is poised to return for the 2016 Olympics in Brazil.

The advertisers picked up on the Olympic spirit. Proctor and Gamble paid tribute to the mothers of Olympic athletes. They showed moms cheering for their young children and then cheering them as Olympians. Kelloggs highlights that Olympic sports are the same for both young and old. And, right after Rebecca Soni broke the 2:20 mark and set a new world record in the 200 m breaststroke, AT&T showed a teenage swimmer seeing that vision of success and setting her mark to beat the world record some day.

Reflecting on all of these stories and more, I have extracted seven principles that schools can learn from the Olympic games. These principles provide a stark contrast to the standards-based college readiness movement.

1. Schools should make it easy for children to participate in authentic experiences. Most people enter a sport through a simpler form of the game that retains the key features. The Olympic sport of soccer is one of the most popular sports in the world precisely because children can make soccer balls and goals out of almost anything, such as old rags for a ball and garbage cans for soccer goals. Children start gymnastics with foam balance beams that rest on the floor and specialized high bars that are lower and have thinner bars for kids to grip. In the realm of science, 1st graders can repeat Newton's gravity experiments with fresh eyes using a book and paper as the objects.

2. Schools should focus on and promote what is fun about academic subjects. Children will continue to participate in sports to the extent that they have fun. Landon Donovan is one of the elite members of the U.S. men's soccer team. What initially drew him to soccer was the enjoyment of the game and the camaraderie. The American Youth Soccer Organization (AYSO), the nation's largest recreational soccer association, explicitly has fun as one of its philosophical underpinnings. Donovan continued to play AYSO soccer for the fun of it, even after he started playing on competitive teams. Likewise, children pursue academic subjects outside of school to the extent that they find the subject fun.

3. Since children develop at different rates, schools should support students beginning a subject at different ages. It is possible to start playing many sports at any age. My father-in-law first took up skiing at the age of 70 and skied actively for several years. Christian Okoye was a Nigerian-born track and field star, who attended Azusa Pacific University. He won seven NCAA titles in shotput, discus, and hammer throw. When his native country of Nigeria failed to select him for the 1984 Olympic team, Okoye started playing college football. He went on to become an all star running back for the Kansas City Chiefs. Julia Child was also a college athlete. Her height gave her an advantage in golf, tennis, and basketball. She majored in English and worked as a copyeditor. During World War II, she worked as a top secret researcher in the Office of Strategic Services, a precursor to the CIA. She married a fellow OSS specialist and moved with him to France after the war. At the age of 36, Child abandoned her training and went to the Le Cordon Bleu cooking school in Paris. She is still one of the most well known chefs throughout the world.

4. Since there are so many areas in which students can become experts, schools should refrain from requiring expertise on an extremely narrow set of subjects. The United States Olympic team won gold medals in fifteen different sports as wide ranging as archery and shooting to wrestling, judo, and boxing to swimming, track and field, and cycling to a wide range of team sports. It is impossible to discern some meaningful set of skills that underlie all of these sports, yet winners of these disparate sports all earn the same honor of being an Olympic gold medalist. Likewise, the adult world has a wide range of areas in which students can develop expertise, but do not share any meaningful underlying set of common skills. By narrowly defining "college readiness" we limit our country's success in the same way that the United States would win fewer gold medals if we required every Olympic athlete to be an expert triathlete.

5. Schools should provide students with visions of success that can drive interest in a variety of a fields. After the U. S. women's gymnastic team won the team gold medal, Bob Costas interviewed the team members on NBC's prime time show. He asked the gymnasts when they had first dreamt of winning the Olympics. Each member of the team said the moment came for them while watching the triumph of either the 1996 U. S women's team on DVD or the 2004 U. S. women's team live. In their book, Becoming Adult, Csikszentmihalyi and Schneider present evidence that students learn about careers from their family in elementary school, from schools in middle school, and from the community in high school. Visions of success are scarce in low income families and communities. Schools should be a place that provide students with visions of success.

6. Only when students develop the desire should schools encourage practice for the sake of development. Coaches don't usually introduce athletes to a sport through intense drill and practice. Potential athletes are introduced to a sport by playing the game. Those that want to improve their skills are now motivated to engage in the monotony of drill and practice since it serves a greater purpose of interest to them. In his book Outliers, Malcolm Gladwell contends that it takes 10,000 hours of practice to develop expertise in any endeavor. He argues that the success of charter school networks like KIPP is based on getting students to spend more time in school. However, it is crucial to understand the motivation for students to spend 10,000 hours in practice. The exceptional people outlined in Outliers were not driven to practice by a desire to get to the next stage in life, but rather they were driven by a deep desire to master their craft. Fostering deep desire as a precursor to practice is absent from any school reform discussions.

7. Accountability in schools should be tied to outcomes of importance, not simple indicators of important outcomes From the beginning of playing a sport, children can distinguish success from failure. The person or team with the most points or the lowest time is the winner. Having great speed, strength, leaping ability, etc. only matters when it translates into more points or lower times. Spain's national soccer team is known for ball possession. They usually have the ball for significantly more time than their opponents. However, focusing on ball possession as an end unto itself would be detrimental to the ultimate objective of scoring more goals than their opponents. Likewise, rather than making intermediate indicators ends unto themselves, schools need to focus on the actual outcomes that matter for success or failure in each field of study.

Defining success in school based on a narrow set of indicators is extremely detrimental to the success of our country. The primary college readiness indicators perpetuate significant income gaps in school performance that reinforce an endless cycle of intergenerational poverty. May the Olympics inspire our policy makers to envision a new model of education that values the diversity of successful avenues in life and inspires unique greatness in every student.

Monday, July 23, 2012

Olympic Readiness Standards

The 2012 London Olympic games open this week. The Olympics is a celebration of international sporting competition featuring over 10,000 athletes from 205 countries competing in 302 events across 26 Olympic sports. These athletes are at the top of their game and in great physical condition. They stand in stark contrast to the average couch potato who will spend several hours each day watching the events. This couch potato culture has led to over one-third of U.S. adults being labeled obese as defined by the U.S. Center of Disease Control.

The problem of adult obesity begins in childhood. Almost one in five children are considered obese in America. This rate represents a three-fold increase since the 1980 boycott of the Moscow Olympics. Even though the number of athletes and countries involved in the Olympics has doubled in the last three decades, the rate of athleticism in the U.S. has significantly declined.

The CDC has identified the low quality of physical education programs in U.S. schools as a significant contributor to this childhood obesity problem. Current physical education standards lack sufficient rigor. They merely set expectations that students lead active lives when they leave school. We need to address the problem of childhood obesity through more rigorous physical education standards. What's needed is an Olympics-for-all movement. While it is not possible for every athlete to compete in the Olympics, it is important for us to create Olympic readiness standards, so that all students leave our education system prepared to lead lives at the highest levels of physical fitness.

In order to manage the Olympic readiness standards at scale, we need to focus on a small set of sports that are predictive of performance in the 26 Olympic sports. The triathlon seems like the most viable option to serve as the core of the Olympic readiness standards. It is actually three sports in one: swimming, cycling, and distance running. It is one of the most grueling competition formats. The pinnacle event is the Ironman competition in which simply finishing the race grants the finisher the title of Ironman. As an elite sport in itself, the triathlon provides a great preparation for the Olympics, yet it is extremely approachable as there are triathlon events in every community.

A major challenge in addressing the Olympic readiness standards is that the triathlete community is fairly homogeneous. Almost 90% of U.S. triathletes are Caucasian and the average annual household income is $126,000. This homogeneity is also present in the individual sports that make up the triathlon. Almost 80% of college distance runners and around 85% of college swimmers are Caucasian. In order to equalize the playing field for everyone, we will need a significant capital investment in our schools to ensure that every school has a regulation swimming pool and high quality road bicycles. Arrangements need to be made with local communities to find safe routes for all students to engage in long distance training. It is also important that we provide incentives for mostly Caucasian, upper class triathletes to move into poor, minority neighborhoods to provide triathlon training, if only for two years.

The list of issues could go on, but let's pause here before your eyes glaze over with $ signs. If you have reached this point in the essay and you are thinking-"Wow, Olympic readiness standards would be a great idea!"- I have failed to adequately portray the ridiculousness of this idea. While many schools in poor neighborhoods are in great need of infrastructure investment, Olympic readiness standards would be a terrible justification. The Olympic readiness standards are, of course, a parody of the standards-based movement.

Just as the triathlon would serve as the core of the Olympic readiness standards for all 26 Olympic sports, the standards-based movement has selected math puzzles and word games as the core of the college readiness standards for the 45 fields of undergraduate study tracked by the U.S. Department of Education's annual digest of education statistics. Although the triathlon is a great indicator of overall athletic ability, it fails as an adequate predictor of specific sports that distantly share the same underlying skills as the triathlon. Likewise, math puzzles and word games are a great indicator of overall academic ability, but they fail as adequate predictors of specific undergraduate fields of study that emphasize different sets of academic abilities.

As you watch the Olympic games over the next few weeks, think about how impoverished our games would become if we focused on a narrow set of skills as prerequisite for entrance to the games. It will serve as a reminder of how impoverished our universities and our society are by focusing on such a narrow set of skills as the gatekeeper to social mobility.

Next, month I will share my experiences of watching the games and reflect on how the Olympics could serve as a model for a new more inclusive set of college readiness standards.

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

Root Canal Reform

One morning earlier this month, I woke up with a severe tooth ache. I could not understand why this was happening, since my dentist has always told me that I take good care of my teeth. Upon visiting the endodontist, I found out there was a crack in my tooth that was imperceptible to x-rays. Bacteria was able to enter through the crack and kill the nerves. At that point the root became a festering cauldron. The only solution was to drill into the tooth, extract the festering material along with the dead nerves, fill the void with benign material, and cap the tooth. The tooth is now dead on the inside, but remains functional.

If you have ever experienced uncontrollable pain, you know that your mind wanders in strange places. Once the endodontist had performed his magic, it dawned on me that a root canal is an apt metaphor for current standards-based reform efforts using Race to the Top funding. Our poorest schools are suffering. The standards-based storyline for this suffering is that there a too many low quality teachers in our poorest schools. Many of the new teacher evaluation systems required for Race to the Top funding are designed to root out festering teachers. By extracting the festering teachers or even closing down whole schools with too many festering teachers, the argument is that performance will improve.

However, lacking in these discussions is any robust plan for replacing all of the festering teachers. Our poorest schools have the most difficult time filling vacancies. Just like a root canal, the plan seems to be that nothing is better than something. By filling the void with inert material and capping it with zero tolerance discipline, we can end up with functional schools that are completely dead on the inside.

What root canal reform ignores is all of the evidence indicating that it is the team that matters more than the individual. More than a decade ago, Hank Becker found that teachers could perform above their abilities if surrounded by good teachers. Researchers in Australia have found that high performing teacher teams have a strong process of enculturating new team members and building collective responsibility. Researchers at the Consortium on Chicago School Research have found that strong teacher teams, built on a foundation of trust, are a powerful tool for improving student performance. Instead, root canal reform fosters mistrust, which destroys teams.

An alternative to root canal reform focused on individual teachers could be reform by the Lenovo stat, which is the NBA's tool for measuring the power of teamwork. Shaquille O'Neal is among the most dominant centers in the NBA, yet during the 2006 NBA finals, the Lenovo stats show that surrounded by the wrong teammates, his squad performed worse than any other combination of players. It is not the quality of the individual players that matters, but the quality of the combination of players that makes the biggest difference. Applying these principles to education recognizes that teaching is a team effort and that districts need to think very carefully how they compose teams before they lay all the blame on individuals.

Saturday, April 14, 2012

Pickett's Charge and the Carnage of Standards-based Reform

Many consider Pickett's Charge to be the fulcrum of the civil war. For most of the war, Lee's Confederate army successfully played defense against the Union army. However, when Lee shifted from defense to offense it changed the tide of the war. The offensive campaign came to a head at Gettysburg, where the Union army had gained a superior defensive position. At the culmination of the battle, Lee ordered a frontal assault into the heart of the Union defenses. Even though Pickett's brigade was only able to reach the outermost Union defenses, he still lost over half of his troops. After three days of battle, Gettysburg resulted in the greatest carnage of any Civil War battle and the Confederate army suffered the brunt of those casualties. Lee's army never recovered from the loss.

Ries and Trout have taken the lessons of military strategy and applied them to corporate marketing. They chronicle a myriad of companies that repeat Lee's mistake of launching a frontal assault against a well defended opponent. The end result is corporate carnage. Companies that hold an inferior position in the marketplace should not launch a frontal attack against a well defended opponent. Instead, they should choose their battles lines carefully so as to gain the tactical advantage at the point of attack.

This same metaphorical military lesson can be applied to college readiness. As with other competitive situations, military strategy can be used to characterize the competition involved in college admissions. Just like General Lee, school systems continue to launch students from underprivileged families headlong into battle against students enjoying a superior defensive position. The battlefields are the standardized tests that both systematically favor students from wealthy families and systematically label underprivileged schools and students as subpar (Duncan & Brooks-Dunn). Is it any wonder that the carnage among our nation's "dropout factories" rivals that of Pickett's Charge?

For many people, it makes intuitive sense to insist that underperforming schools work harder, work smarter, or face closure. And after 10 years of No Child Left Behind and almost 30 years since a Nation at Risk, students from underprivileged families have indeed significantly improved their academic outcomes. Despite these improvements, underprivileged students still have lost ground on college entrance rates to wealthier students. Wealthy students are now four times more likely to attend a competitive college than poor students; whereas, forty years ago wealthy students were only two times more likely to attend a competitive school than poor students (Bastedo & Jaquette, Table 3). In battle, those in a superior defensive position grow stronger over time, and those engaged in frontal assault grow weaker.

Ries and Trout offer a ray of hope for people who are outmatched on the battlefield: change the battlefield by outflanking your opponent. They describe how Apple Computer did just that to IBM with the Macintosh computer in 1984. Apple invented a new market for graphical personal computers, which took rivals years to replicate. However, Apple fumbled its lead and was near death in the mid 1990s. The pursuit is as important as the initial victory. Fortunately, Apple recovered by again changing the battlefields. This time they reinvented the marketplace for music players, cell phones, and tablet computers. They are now one of the world's largest companies.

In the battle for higher education, the state of Texas has also changed the battlefield. Students who graduate in the top 10% of their high school class are automatically admitted to the Texas university of their choice, regardless of their test scores. Critics have protested that students from underprivileged schools couldn't possibly compete in the college classroom against their better matched rivals. However, despite the critics, underprivileged students have shown that not only can they outcompete their lower ranked rivals in the classroom, but also in overall graduation rates as well (Niu & Tienda, Figure 3). It seems that being a big fish in a small pond is a better way to prepare for college than being a small fish in a big pond. As an added bonus, students from underprivileged schools are much more likely to major in STEM fields than their lower ranked rivals. Therefore, focusing on class rank not only can increase the diversity of college graduates (Bastedo & Jaquette, Figures 4 & 5), but also seems like a sound strategy for increasing the diversity of STEM fields.

The standardization of the standards-based movement has solidified the homogenization of the population at our nation's competitive colleges as mostly white middle- to upper-income students (Dickerson & Jacobs). The resulting carnage perpetuated on underprivileged black and Hispanic students has made it difficult for them to succeed even in noncompetitive colleges. To achieve the national goal of diversifying the ranks of our college graduates, administrators need to rethink how they can diversify the college admissions process. Relying primarily on tests that favor wealthy students perpetuates the fallacy that those tests are good predictors of college performance. As we have seen, something as simple as shifting the entrance criteria to class rank can have huge effects on diversification, while maintaining or exceeding success rates. I wonder what other high risk-high reward ideas can create opportunities for underprivileged youth to compete from their areas of strength and outflank their wealthier peers for entrance to competitive colleges.

Tuesday, March 29, 2005

Tougher Graduation Requirements

In 1983 the secretary of education under President Reagan released a report entitled, “A Nation at Risk.” A famous line from that report conjectured that if a foreign nation had imposed upon us this mediocre system of schooling, the U.S. would consider it an act of war. At that time, the major threat was the Soviet Union on the security front and Japan on the economic front. Japanese companies had surged in the late seventies in technology and manufacturing. Calling for raising academic standards, A Nation at Risk became the genesis of the standards-based movement that emerged in the early 1990’s and has made the No Child Left Behind legislation possible. Every state but Iowa has established state standards and has a state testing system. In addition to raising academic standards, the report also called for strengthening the graduation requirements in core topic areas: language arts, math, and science.

Two decades later, terrorism has replaced the Soviet Union as the primary security threat and globalization, particularly outsourcing and the “China Price,” have replaced Japan as the primary economic threat. The solution remains the same. The Wall Street Journal reported today on a stiffening of high school graduation requirements across several states. A major proponent of this movement is Achieve, Inc., a business-backed educational policy nonprofit. Board members include the likes of former IBM CEO Lou Gerstner and former Intel CEO Craig Barret.

While A Nation at Risk spurred a strengthening of at least rudimentary graduation requirements in math and science, the article highlights efforts in a number of states seeking to increase the number of math and science courses needed for graduation. The goal is to move beyond rudimentary requirements to requiring all students to successfully complete a college prep sequence of math and science. According to Becoming Adult a study by Csikszentmihalyi and Schneider, the most important factor influencing whether a high school student attends a four-year college is successful completion of high-level math and science courses. Requiring students to take higher-level math and science courses will maximize opportunities for graduating high school students.

However, the article cites that such moves will increase the cost of doing business. In many cases it will require hiring more math and science teachers at a time when qualified math and science teachers are already in high demand. In addition, to accommodate more science courses will require constructing more lab-equipped classrooms. Texas estimates it will cost $200 million to equip enough classrooms to accommodate an increase of 200,000 students taking additional science courses.

Toshmo, R. (2005, March 29). “Diploma bar is getting higher at many U.S. high schools,” Wall Street Journal, B1, B4.

Fewer Engineering Offspring

From 1975 to 2000, the U.S. dropped from 3rd to 17th worldwide rank in the number of engineers it produces. The Wall Street Journal reports continuous concern over this decrease in engineers. A number of tech executives warn that this trend will have a significant impact on the United States’ long-term competitiveness. In an interesting ironic twist, these same engineering executives report that they are having a hard time interesting their own children to pursue careers in engineering. The offspring cite several reasons for their lack of interest. First is a fear that there will not be engineering opportunities in the U.S. since engineering jobs are being outsourced to India. A second reason is a lack of interest based on their experiences in school. About 120,000 students start off in engineering. However, only about half graduate. The article also cites poor math and science curricula as well as persistent image problems. Engineers are often thought of as socially awkward or obsessed with work.

It is interesting to note that in a study by Csikszentmihalyi and Schneider called Becoming Adult, engineering was in the top 10 careers that middle and high school students thought they would pursue after college. Why is there such a big gap between interest at the middle school level and graduation of engineers from college? I personally do not buy the argument that it is simply a factor of poor public education. The 120,000 freshman who start out in engineering are an elite class. To make it into an engineering program, these students made it through an advanced sequence of math and science courses in high school and have scored well on their SAT’s. The offspring highlighted in the article did not cite lack of ability as the reason for leaving, but rather lack of interest. It seems like programs aimed at retaining students in engineering programs would have more bang for the buck. A one hundred percent retention rate would double the number of engineering graduates and vault the U.S. back to the top of the world rank.

Grimes, A. (2005, March 29). “Even tech execs can’t get kids to be engineers,” Wall Street Journal, B1, B6.

Monday, March 28, 2005

Bill Gates’ Think Week

When I graduated from Northwestern University with a B.S. in education and computer programming, I was invited to interview with Microsoft in Redmond, WA. I interviewed with members of the MS Word and Encarta development teams. Each of the developers that interviewed me posed interesting programming challenges and asked me to sketch proposed algorithms on white boards in their office. During the course of each interview I also mentioned that my long-term interest was developing educational software and perhaps Microsoft would be interested in that market. Finally, one of the programmers told me that Bill Gates is not interested in educational software. I ended up not getting a job at Microsoft.

I have no idea whether that programmer is still at Microsoft, but how times have changed. The Wall Street Journal was invited to visit with Bill Gates on one of his twice-annual Think Weeks. Gates secludes himself in an undisclosed retreat location for one week to focus on the future directions of technology and Microsoft’s strategic positioning. In his most recent Think Week, Gates read roughly 100 papers in eight topic areas. One of those topic areas was education. Gates read a paper by Craig Bartholomew, the general manager of the education group, in which Bartholomew discusses recommendations for how Microsoft’s core products can better address the education market. Apparently, the paper was well received and Bartholomew reports that, “People in my group are optimistic now.”

Given Gates’ active interest in education policy both through the Gates Foundation and through his public comments about the state of education (e.g. National Governors summit on high school reform), it is clear that Gates has taken a keen interest in improving education. It will be interesting to see what Microsoft’s education technology strategy will be.

Guth, R. A. (2005, March 28). “In secret hideaway, Bill Gates ponders Microsoft’s future,” Wall Street Journal, A1.